Dictionaries And Help With Writing Crossword Clues
There are two main reasons for this:
Firstly, dictionary definitions tend to be quite long and rambling, and certainly far too long for most puzzles, particularly quick crosswords which are the most popular crossword variant both to be solved and seen in publications. These tend to require short and snappy definitions, so dictionary definitions tend to be of little use here.
Secondly, and much more frustratingly for crossword compilers, dictionary definitions are extraordinarily uninformative for a really large number of words. You soon realise that you didn't learn what a large number of words meant from the dictionary. This is because there is a huge amount of circularity in dictionary definitions: for instance virtually every part of a word is simply defined by its root, thus "quietness: the quality or state of being quiet", and "lawyer: a person who studies law". If you don't already know what 'quiet' means or anything about the concept of 'law' these aren't much help. From the point of view of the compiler, the one thing you can't do in crosswords is to use part of the solution word in the clue, for obvious reasons, and so such definitions don't help with clue-writing at all.
Thirdly, there is a problem not just with circularity, but that many dictionary definitions essentially state the obvious, or use one of both words in a compound noun in the definition: thus "bedroom: a room for sleeping in": now no-one writing a crossword clue should accept using 'room' in a clue where the answer is 'bedroom'. No doubt some dictionaries go further and define a bedroom as a room with a bed in it!
In summary, most words that are easy to clue have lots of fairly obvious synonyms that you can use. Most difficult words - when you perhaps look to the dictionary to help you come up with an idea for a clue - either have a circular definition or use part of the solution word in the clue, and are therefore not much use for crossword setters.
None of which is to say that dictionaries aren't of some use to setters (for one thing, seeing if a word appears in it, whether it is hyphenated etc) but it is just that when it comes to the clue writing process, dictionaries are not very useful at all.
Are you a crossword writer? If so, how useful do you find dictionaries in writing your clues? If not very useful, then what tools do you use - other than your own brain - to help you write your clues?
Date written: 28 Apr 2015
Comment on this post
You must be logged in to comment - please Register or Login
Why No Wordsearch At Wordy Puzzle
We have a huge range of word puzzles here at Wordy Puzzle, representing all the major puzzle types. All of them, that is, apart from the wordsearch puzzle. Just in case you've not come across it before, a wordsearch is a simple word puzzle that features...
Added: 21 Jun 2015
What Makes A Valid Crossword Grid?
What constitutes a valid crossword grid varies from country to country. Here we focus on what counts as a valid grid in the UK.
- Firstly, the grid dimensions should be odd, eg 13 x 13 or 15 x 15; these are the two most common grid sizes. In the vast...
Added: 07 Apr 2015
Cryptic Clues That Refer To Other Clues
Clues that refer to other clues in the grid are quite common when solving cryptic crosswords, and also occasionally appear in quick crosswords, although less often.
In the latter case the referencing is usually quite straightforward, such as simply an...
Added: 20 Apr 2015
Introduction To Word Fit Puzzles
Word fit puzzles are one of those types of puzzle that have a huge range of different names: you might know it as letter fit, or kriss kross, or indeed as criss cross. Whatever you know it as, the rules are the same: place each word into the grid once....
Added: 24 Apr 2015
Cryptic Crossword Anagram Indicators
When solving a cryptic crossword one thing you can be sure of is that there will be some anagram clues, or partial anagram clues, in the solving mix.
Some cryptic crosswords have over 50% of the clues containing anagrams in some form, whilst even the...
Added: 16 Apr 2015
Back to Puzzle Blog













