Homophone Clues In Cryptic Crosswords
One of the clue types that people often struggle with is the homophone clue, or soundalike clue.
These are words or phrases that have the same pronunciation but different meanings. With homophone clues in cryptics, the words are always spelt differently. As an example, MINED and MIND clearly mean very different things, but they have the same pronunciation.
The homophone clue exploits this and so you will need to say the word in your head and think of other words that sound the same to help you reach the answer. Some people find this harder than other, and indeed some clues are more obscure than others, particularly if they expect you to use some fairly strange dialectical way of pronouncing a word that may be alien to you.
Homophone clues include an indication to the fact that you should use your ear, such as 'we hear' or 'on the radio' or 'by the sound of it', so in that sense they are quite easy to identify, compared to most other clue types that don't announce themselves quite as readily. Whilst these clues are often telegraphed, they are nevertheless often very hard to solve, as they can require quite a bit of lateral thinking to take you to the answer.
Let's look at an example clue:
Taxi cost heard to be reasonable (4)
Here taxi cost is FARE and reasonable is FAIR.
One of the complaints people have with homophone clues is that it is not always clear which word the setter wants for the answer, and on occasion this can lead to apparent multiple answers.
For instance if the meanings are 'fair' and 'fare' as above, then which one does the setter want you to use for the answer? In the example above should we read the clue as 'taxi cost, heard to be reasonable' or as 'taxi cost heard, to be reasonable': note that the position of the comma changes what the answer word is, or essentially, are we supposed to 'hear' the word FARE to get FAIR or hear the word FAIR to get FARE as the answer?
Usually the letters in the grid whittle it down to one option, but not always, so the setter using the homophone clue should either indicate the answer word clearly, or check that only one of the options fits the letters available. As a setter, if the answers are of the same length, then the homophone indicator should come at the start of the clue to remove this ambiguity: eg "We hear taxi cost to be reasonable" which clearly leads to the answer being FAIR, not FARE.
Date written: 13 Apr 2015
Comment on this post
You must be logged in to comment - please Register or Login
Novelty Crosswords: Missing Vowel Puzzles
A missing vowel puzzle is a type of crossword variant that, as the name implies, is rather light on vowels!
The puzzle is presented as a normal crossword, but with a novel twist: instead of orthodox clues, all the answers appear under the grid, BUT...
Added: 27 Mar 2015
Solving & Lit Clues In Cryptic Crosswords
When you are solving cryptic crosswords, most of the clue types that you come across are fairly intuitive: for instance a double definition clue fairly obviously involves two definitions that lead to the same answer. And an anagram clue, sure enough,...
Added: 11 Apr 2015
Cryptic Clues That Refer To Other Clues
Clues that refer to other clues in the grid are quite common when solving cryptic crosswords, and also occasionally appear in quick crosswords, although less often.
In the latter case the referencing is usually quite straightforward, such as simply an...
Added: 20 Apr 2015
What Is A Nina?
Well, the first thing to say about Nina, is that it is a name. But in the context of crosswords, it means something quite different indeed.
A nina virtually always only appears in cryptic crosswords, and some authors are well-known for including them...
Added: 05 Apr 2015
Does Brain Training Work?
Does brain training work? This is a big question, and there have been several tests and surveys carried out - some more scientific than others - to try and establish the truth.
Anecdotally at least, several people say that they have experienced...
Added: 23 Apr 2015
Back to Puzzle Blog